 | Andrew McCumiskey (SRA) | Nae idea, only interested in SESLers! | Dickson or Paton surely?? |
 | Kevin Hull (AI) | Lionel Messi | Such a joy watching him play. Though, there's one player I enjoy watching more. Young lad at Ajax. Frenkie de Jong. Remember that name! |
 | Josh Fitzgerald (INV) | Nae idea, only interested in SESLers! | We need an “other” option. The answer is undoubtedly, Kylian Mbappe. |
 | James White (MON) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
 | John McCarthy (LIV) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Cameron Archibald (ARB) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Steve Gregory (COV) | Cristiano Ronaldo | Can't say I am a massive Ronaldo fan but his ability can't be questioned. He is a machine. Messi had a bobbins World Cup so that's fine I pick Ronaldo. |
 | Dave Smyth (HEA) | Cristiano Ronaldo | Modric maybe, but Real Madrid mid table without Ronaldo |
 | Lee Elkins (CB) | Lionel Messi | |
 | William Bushby (EDI) | Nae idea, only interested in SESLers! | Gareth Bale, when he's fully fit... |
 | Bryce Kalmbach (QP) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Derek Purvis (BER) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Paul Roseblade (AYR) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Tyron Barnard (EST) | Nae idea, only interested in SESLers! | |
 | Stephen Williams (PET) | Lionel Messi | Statistically far and away the best |
 | Colin Scott (DUM) | Lionel Messi | |
 | James Tucker (RR) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Daniel Fitzgerald (ANN) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Mark Boland (DUU) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Matthew White (SM) | Lionel Messi | |
 | Arnold Yzermans (QOS) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
 | Bill Ramsay (RAN) | Cristiano Ronaldo | Don’t like him but can’t argue with ability or work ethic |
 | Simon Bijker (BRE) | Cristiano Ronaldo | At the age of 71 I have seen them all including Pele, and Ronaldo wins it EASY |
 | Rob Lye (ROS) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
 | David Blair (HIB) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
 | Raymond Cini (PT) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
 | Willy Krosnyak (FOR) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
 | Leon Permentier (DEV) | Nae idea, only interested in SESLers! | |
 | Les Lithgo (HAM) | Cristiano Ronaldo | compare Madrid team to juve team now. Matchwinner |
 | Richard Burnett (NAI) | Luka Modric | |
 | Paul Cockayne (EF) | Lionel Messi | |