| Andy Shaw (FAL) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Bill Ramsay (RAN) | Lionel Messi | |
| Richard Burnett (NAI) | Lionel Messi | Bale shouldn't even be in the final 23 |
| Paul Roseblade (AYR) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| David Blair (HIB) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Daniel Fitzgerald (ANN) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Derek Purvis (BER) | Lionel Messi | |
| David Campbell (KIL) | Cristiano Ronaldo | Battle for 3rd after Cris & Lio. Neymar, Muller, Suarez or Lewandowski. |
| Josh Fitzgerald (INV) | Cristiano Ronaldo | I'm a Messi fan but Ronaldo's achievement as greatest ever Real scorer in so few matches will swing it. |
| Tyron Barnard (EST) | Lionel Messi | |
| William Bushby (EDI) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Matthew White (SM) | your own SESL player? | Rob Green. The greatness of his howler echoes through eternity. |
| Ricky Hawthorn (STE) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Andrew McCumiskey (SRA) | Gareth Bale | |
| Colin Scott (DUM) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Steve Gregory (COV) | your own SESL player? | Couldn't give a flying toss (I'm surprised that wasn't available as an option this time). |
| Rob Lye (ROS) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| Paul Cockayne (EF) | Lionel Messi | |
| Bryce Kalmbach (QP) | Lionel Messi | |
| Kevin Hull (AI) | Cristiano Ronaldo | no Rooney! |
| John McCarthy (LIV) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| James Tucker (RR) | your own SESL player? | Odion Ighalo. For his performance in SESL and for Watford. 24 goals and counting in the calendar year. |
| Stephen Williams (PET) | your own SESL player? | Nigel Short! |
| Arnold Yzermans (QOS) | Cristiano Ronaldo | |
| James White (MON) | Cristiano Ronaldo | leg-end |