
| Overall | Div 1 | |
| Wins | 732 | 290 |
| Draws | 286 | 131 |
| Losses | 733 | 359 |
| Pct. | 0.500 | 0.456 |
| Mike Morton (S1-7), Richard Burnett (S2-3), |
| M | DATE | SCORE | OPPONENT | COMPETITION | HEAD TO HEAD RESULTS | LAST MATCH | |||
| 1 | Nov 29 | D | 0 - 0 | West Bromwich Baggies | SFLSL Cup | Series even at 11-4-11 | |||
| 2 | Nov 30 | L | 0 - 3 | Copernicus Town | SFLSL Cup | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 14-7-7 | |||
| 3 | Dec 03 | L | 1 - 5 | @ | Montevideo Tricolores | SFLSL Cup | Montevideo Tricolores lead series 32-12-29 | ||
| 4 | Dec 06 | L | 0 - 3 | @ | West Bromwich Baggies | SFLSL Cup | Series even at 11-4-11 | ||
| 5 | Dec 07 | D | 2 - 2 | @ | Copernicus Town | SFLSL Cup | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 14-7-7 | ||
| 6 | Dec 10 | W | 3 - 2 | Montevideo Tricolores | SFLSL Cup | Montevideo Tricolores lead series 32-12-29 | |||
| 7 | Dec 13 | W | 3 - 0 | Pehuajo Expos | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 25-10-13 | |||
| 8 | Dec 14 | W | 1 - 0 | @ | Inter Postmen | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 30-9-15 | ||
| 9 | Dec 17 | W | 2 - 1 | Copernicus Town | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 14-7-7 | |||
| 10 | Dec 20 | W | 3 - 2 | @ | Cannons | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 8-5-7 | ||
| 11 | Dec 21 | W | 2 - 0 | Highland Rangers | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 18-6-5 | |||
| 12 | Dec 24 | L | 0 - 4 | @ | Gotham City Knights FC | Dowson Cup | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 15-4-12 | ||
| 13 | Dec 27 | L | 1 - 2 | BIG is Beautiful | SFLSL-2 | BIG is Beautiful lead series 28-7-15 | |||
| 14 | Dec 28 | L | 0 - 1 | @ | West Bromwich Baggies | SFLSL-2 | Series even at 11-4-11 | ||
| 15 | Dec 31 | W | 4 - 0 | Gotham City Knights FC | Dowson Cup | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 15-4-12 | |||
| 16 | Jan 03 | D | 2 - 2 | Newton Heath LYR | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 29-7-8 | |||
| 17 | Jan 04 | L | 4 - 7 | @ | Golden Dragons | SFLSL-2 | Golden Dragons lead series 26-4-15 | ||
| 19 | Jan 10 | L | 0 - 4 | Camelot FC | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 18-4-10 | |||
| 20 | Jan 11 | L | 0 - 2 | @ | FC Blades | SFLSL-2 | FC Blades lead series 23-5-3 | ||
| 21 | Jan 14 | W | 4 - 3 | Merrylee Maestros | SFLSL-2 | Merrylee Maestros lead series 26-5-21 | |||
| 22 | Jan 17 | W | 5 - 0 | Silverx Surfers | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 36-6-10 | |||
| 23 | Jan 18 | D | 0 - 0 | @ | Pehuajo Expos | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 25-10-13 | ||
| 25 | Jan 24 | W | 2 - 0 | Inter Postmen | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 30-9-15 | |||
| 26 | Jan 25 | W | 4 - 1 | @ | Copernicus Town | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 14-7-7 | ||
| 27 | Jan 28 | W | 1 - 0 | (n) | Sheffield Rovers | Dowson Cup | Sheffield Rovers lead series 45-11-26 | ||
| 28 | Jan 31 | W | 3 - 0 | Cannons | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 8-5-7 | |||
| 29 | Feb 01 | L | 1 - 2 | @ | Highland Rangers | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 18-6-5 | ||
| 31 | Feb 07 | W | 5 - 2 | @ | BIG is Beautiful | SFLSL-2 | BIG is Beautiful lead series 28-7-15 | ||
| 32 | Feb 08 | W | 1 - 0 | West Bromwich Baggies | SFLSL-2 | Series even at 11-4-11 | |||
| 33 | Feb 11 | L | 3 - 8 | (n) | Montevideo Tricolores | Dowson Cup | Montevideo Tricolores lead series 32-12-29 | ||
| 34 | Feb 14 | W | 2 - 0 | @ | Newton Heath LYR | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 29-7-8 | ||
| 35 | Feb 15 | L | 0 - 2 | Golden Dragons | SFLSL-2 | Golden Dragons lead series 26-4-15 | |||
| 37 | Feb 21 | L | 2 - 5 | @ | Camelot FC | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 18-4-10 | ||
| 38 | Feb 22 | D | 3 - 3 | FC Blades | SFLSL-2 | FC Blades lead series 23-5-3 | |||
| 40 | Feb 28 | L | 0 - 6 | @ | Merrylee Maestros | SFLSL-2 | Merrylee Maestros lead series 26-5-21 | ||
| 41 | Mar 01 | W | 4 - 0 | @ | Silverx Surfers | SFLSL-2 | New Jersey Nutmegs lead series 36-6-10 | ||
| 43 | Mar 06 | D | 4 - 4 | (n) | A.C. Sapone | Playoffs | A.C. Sapone lead series 20-9-16 | ||