Firstly, I like the maximum SL. It forces you to adapt, making your training plans more interesting. That said, I was cursing last season when I drafted three completely useless players.

Doing the maths: if you need two rookies each season in the long term, you need at least two train-worthy guys with a maximum SL of e.g. 28.
With three drafts, the probability of getting them is 55%, which is pretty bad.
However, with the extra redraft roll, the probability rises to 74% (two redrafts would make it 85%).

So basically, you currently have to adapt every fourth season. Without the redraft option, it’d be about every second season – too much curses even for my taste!
The redraft option is clearly a crutch, but a good and useful one.

Anyway, there will always be “fourth” seasons (like BIB S49):
You have plenty of options to deal with them (trades, auctions and signings), so it's not really a major issue.

There's no need to change, especially since there were only two redrafts in total last season (BIB and OPT).
The rules work fine and add some spice to the game.

Just noticed #12 was taken by YFC.

So, v2 ...

#18 1/15 MA Harinezura

#89 (#90) 0/6 UT Fin Fang Foom

#12 1/15 SD Fin Fang Foom

#18 1/15 MA Harinezura