| Richard Burnett (DUB) | Choice of 2 | Gk Schumacher or forward Stan bowles |
| Simon Bijker (BIB) | None | Was not a good year. |
| Kev Hull (WBB) | All of them | Hibs have exceeded their pre-season expectations and beat the 'Tic last Sunday.. :-) |
| Sergei Gavino (ORA) | All of them | Great season for Betis. If we're taking about ORA, none of them deserve it. |
| Tyron Barnard (CN) | None | In real life an Arsenal fan, Monreal arguably our player of the year. In SFLSL it was a VERY bad year, so probably one of the suits... |
| Rob Lye (TNS) | All of them | Hard to choose all played well and its a team game |
| Marc Legowski (CPT) | None | |
| Roy Rolsten (LD) | The Star | Everton would go for Pickford. But has to be either Mo or De Bruyne |
| David Campbell (GCK) | The Star | Stephen O'Donnell (Killie) |
| Dan Fitzgerald (SFR) | Choice of 2 | For the BLADES, Leon Clarke (top scorer) & David Brooks (best young player) |
| Andy Shaw (YFC) | None | |
| Carl Oakes (LBC) | Choice of 2 | |
| Les Lithgo (NHL) | The Star | de Gea |
| Mike Hernandez (PEX) | None | |
| Josh Fitzgerald (FCB) | Choice of 2 | GK Peter McCloy & FW Willie Johnston were probably the two with most influence over last season. |
| James White (NJN) | None | |