| Derek Purvis (SEA) | Yes but just in ST TROPHY | could be interesting, extra revenue, more gameplay and could make it little harder to focus on all 3 competitions. |
| David Campbell (CHA) | NO WAY ! | Might add an interesting dimension to EL management but I'm leaning towards no. |
| Andrew Foss-Grant (POR) | NO WAY ! | Don't need any more games |
| Tyler Ponder (ROC) | Yes in Both Cup Competitions | extra money anyday |
| Stephen Williams (HOU) | NO WAY ! | |
| Steve Turner (CLB) | Yes in Both Cup Competitions | I'm easy either way but it might make things interesting! |
| Bryce Kalmbach (ATL) | Yes in Both Cup Competitions | yes one replay only though, so in the replay match it will have to be penalties if its still a draw. |
| James White (KC) | NO WAY ! | Good idea but difficult to fit into schedule |
| Matt White (DC) | Yes in Both Cup Competitions | You want to win a game with playing soccer, not with a shoot out. |
| Rob Lye (PHI) | NO WAY ! | keep it as it is it works |
| Jason Dowson (CAR) | NO WAY ! | Can be a tactical option to play for pens |