| Steve Gregory (COV) | GM Graeme | next best team |
| Lee Elkins (CB) | RAN James | |
| Leon Permentier (DEV) | GM Graeme | With James at RAN as 2nd choice. GM doing well this season and had good SESL Cup last |
| Bill Nicholl (CEL) | RAN James | Maybe James doesn't have his best team this season, but his past successes should count his team in |
| Andrew Foss-Grant (MOT) | RAN James | Rangers have a very experienced manager & competed well in the OLMEC CUP last season |
| Mark Boland (DUU) | GM Graeme | |
| David Campbell (KIL) | Other (please specify) | EF |
| Daniel Roseblade (DFA) | Other (please specify) | East Fife(Oli deserves it) |
| Marc Legowski (PT) | GM Graeme | Reason is active chatty manager with solid team tactics. |
| James Tucker (RR) | RAN James | Highest league finisher in season 21. |
| Richard Burnett (NAI) | GM Graeme | |
| Kevin Hull (AI) | GM Graeme | GM got enthusiasm and the roster. 2nd pick EF as has roster but seems to have lost his way. |
| Tapani Olkku (GM) | AI Stewart | Airdrie's T11 eclipses the rest and T11 is what the OLMEC Cup is all about... IMHO... |
| William Bushby (EDI) | GM Graeme | There can be only one!! |
| Arnold Yzermans (QOS) | RAN James | This is a tough call between Graeme and James, both would be quality additions to the cup. RAN finished 5th, GM 6th so I'm going with James |
| James White (MON) | RAN James | |
| Roy Rolsten (STI) | AI Stewart | AI sneak it on Top11 and participation. RAN boss too quiet. GM i like too. |
| Dave Smyth (HEA) | AI Stewart | Has the better team |
| Alon Atie (FRA) | AI Stewart | 1.AI, 2.GM, 3.STI, 4.RAN. |
| Cameron Archibald (ARB) | GM Graeme | best equipped team of those not qualified |
| Tyron Barnard (EST) | AI Stewart | top Top 11 |
| Raymond Cini (CLY) | GM Graeme | |
| Bill Ramsay (RAN) | GM Graeme | |
| Paul Roseblade (AYR) | GM Graeme | Going strictly on games against fellow olmec cup listees this season, my vote goes to Morton. Airdrie however are the most improved and consistent team in 3 seasons since stewart took over. |
| Willy Krosnyak (FOR) | STI Craig | |
| Stephen Williams (PET) | AI Stewart | AI ball-control could shake up Olmec Cup 2009.
STI on a great run too at top of Div 2. |
| Mark Creasey (STJ) | AI Stewart | The team furthest up the league at the time the entry has to be submitted. |
| Eduard Habermann (DEE) | AI Stewart | |
| David Blair (HIB) | AI Stewart | |
| Les Lithgo (HAM) | GM Graeme | |
| Derek Purvis (BER) | AI Stewart | |
| Colin Scott (DUM) | GM Graeme | My gift is my vote and this one's for Dave... |