| Daniel Fitzgerald (ANN) | Man-marking waste of time | |
| Josh Fitzgerald (INV) | Man-marking waste of time | I've only used it a few times across all leagues so I'm not the best point of reference. |
| Paul Roseblade (AYR) | Man-marking ok sometimes | Make sure you leave your DF in a good state if you use a couple of players to man mark |
| Fran Morillo (BRE) | Man-marking waste of time | |
| Ricky Hawthorn (STE) | Man-marking waste of time | |
| Tyron Barnard (EST) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Leon Permentier (DEV) | Man-marking ok sometimes | It has worked for me but you have to guess their tactics |
| Steve Gregory (COV) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Andrew McCumiskey (SRA) | Man-marking waste of time | Used unsuccessfully couple of times. Not sure it works effectively |
| Stephen Williams (PET) | Man-marking ok sometimes | I used it to good effect vs Rangers early cross tactic this weekend. Definitely has some value. |
| Andy Shaw (FAL) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Derek Purvis (BER) | Man-marking waste of time | |
| David Campbell (KIL) | Man-marking ok sometimes | trial and error |
| Matt Cooper (ALB) | WTF is man-marking !? | |
| Raymond Cini (CLY) | Man-marking is useful | |
| Arnold Yzermans (QOS) | WTF is man-marking !? | |
| Colin Scott (DUM) | Man-marking waste of time | |
| William Bushby (EDI) | other response (comment) | Its a waste of time, I would make it more powerful so manager spend time scouting the other team |
| Daniel Roseblade (DFA) | Man-marking waste of time | |
| Matthew White (SM) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Richard Burnett (NAI) | Man-marking is useful | |
| Mark Boland (DUU) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| James Tucker (RR) | Man-marking is useful | Against good wingers or one stand out FW |
| Marc Legowski (PT) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Dave Smyth (HEA) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Lee Elkins (CB) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Paul Cockayne (EF) | Man-marking is useful | |
| Kevin Hull (AI) | Man-marking is useful | |
| John McCarthy (LIV) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| James White (MON) | WTF is man-marking !? | |
| Andrew Foss-Grant (MOT) | Man-marking ok sometimes | |
| Willy Krosnyak (FOR) | Man-marking is useful | I think |