| Bill Nicholl (CEL) | Yes, give it a try | I don't buy apprentices as starting SL too low, but this good for other teams. |
| Cameron Archibald (ARB) | type other comment | Not a silly idea at all….but I think the league is all about balance. If anything unbalances it then it would be tricky to sort it. I’m on the fence until someone convinced me it wouldn’t royally cock things up 😊 |
| William Bushby (EDI) | No, sounds silly | |
| Paul Cockayne (EF) | Yes, give it a try | |
| Andrew Foss-Grant (MOT) | No, sounds silly | Don't love the random gambling part. Perhaps if the boost was smaller I could get behind it |
| Matt Cooper (ALB) | No, sounds silly | |
| Dave Smyth (HEA) | Yes, give it a try | Change can be fun. I don't buy 0/5 but could help other teams re-build. |
| Ricky Hawthorn (STE) | Yes, give it a try | |
| Bill Ramsay (RAN) | type other comment | Don't think it's a silly idea, but don't think it will add much to the game. |
| Andy Shaw (FAL) | No, sounds silly | |
| Alon Atie (FRA) | No, sounds silly | sorry...just my 2 cents |
| David Campbell (KIL) | Yes, give it a try | Not a bad idea. Tiered by division as per blog idea could be good |
| Andrew McCumiskey (SRA) | type other comment | Another variant might be 'Teenage Prodigy'. +2/+3 SL at end of season to randomly drawn Age 0. |
| Daniel Fitzgerald (ANN) | Yes, give it a try | I think keeping the idea of helping D3>D2>D1 with extra chances would be worth working in |
| Alan Bishop (COW) | Yes, give it a try | |
| James Tucker (RR) | type other comment | I don't like the random nature. But yes to a Superstar Upgrade. Maybe scaled in cost by league position finish? |
| Willy Krosnyak (FOR) | type other comment | We have tried that on another league a long time ago and it did not work well in the sense that those stars were very determining to the fate of their teams... |
| Steve Gregory (COV) | Yes, give it a try | 3 stars Div 3, 2 for Div 2, and one for Div 1 ? |
| James White (MON) | Yes, give it a try | But 3 managers will like it and 45 will hate it ;-p |
| Arnold Yzermans (QOS) | Yes, give it a try | |
| Mark Creasey (STJ) | Yes, give it a try | I open to try new suggestions |
| Tyron Barnard (EST) | No, sounds silly | |
| Derek Purvis (BER) | Yes, give it a try | |
| Eduard Habermann (DEE) | No, sounds silly | |
| Colin Scott (DUM) | No, sounds silly | |
| Kevin Hull (AI) | Yes, give it a try | |
| John McCarthy (LIV) | No, sounds silly | |
| Daniel Roseblade (DFA) | Yes, give it a try | go on then |